In recent months, the European electricity market has exhibited fluctuations reminiscent of a rollercoaster rideParticularly notable was a peak in electricity prices across multiple countries in December 2024, which set a new record for the year, only to be followed days later by several hours of negative pricing fueled by a spike in electricity generationThis paradoxical scenario leaves observers puzzled as to how electricity prices can oscillate so dramatically.

The situation peaked on January 1, when Germany, the continent's largest electricity market, experienced a wind energy surge reaching 40 gigawatts, substantially surpassing demandThis surplus led to a remarkable drop in the market price of electricity, dipping below zero for four consecutive hoursSuch negative pricing indicates that not only are electricity producers not compensated, but they sometimes pay to transmit power to the grid.

However, this unusual phenomenon was short-lived, as by January 6, the intraday prices had rebounded slightly to around 0.03 euros per kilowatt-hour

Advertisements

Negative prices have not been confined to Germany; other European nations, including the UK, France, Finland, and Spain, have similarly encountered negative pricing scenariosThe underlying cause of this trend largely relates to the increasing capacity of renewable energy sourcesAs Europe intensifies its energy transition efforts, it is anticipated that negative pricing will become a more frequent occurrence.

Experts have expressed that while negative pricing might provide temporary relief, it won't resolve the broader issue of high industrial electricity prices in GermanyThis persistent high pricing remains a significant hurdle for the country’s economic recoveryThe volatility in electricity prices has also revealed new challenges for the European electricity system.

Statistics from the European Power Exchange indicate that the duration of negative pricing in the European electricity market hit a record high in 2024. Germany alone recorded 468 hours of negative pricing—a 60% increase compared to the previous year

Advertisements

In France, traditionally known for its nuclear power, negative pricing hours more than doubled to 356 hours, while Spain saw negative prices for the first time last year, totaling 247 hoursThe UK experienced a 70% increase in negative hours as well, with a total of 179 hours.

According to Eurelectric, there is approximately a 17% chance of encountering negative pricing in at least one bidding area within EuropeProfessor Liu Ximei from the North China Electric Power University elaborated that in observing recent intraday market trading, negative prices are predominantly being recorded in power products with expiry times of 60, 30, and 15 minutes, particularly during off-peak late-night hoursThis scenario arises due to a concentrated output from renewable energy sources, notably wind energy, coupled with weakened electricity demand and significant shortfalls in energy storage capacities, making it difficult to achieve timely demand-side responses and maintain system balance.

Recent reports from the European Power Industry Association disclosed that in 2024, renewable energy accounted for a historic 48% of the EU's total electricity generation, while nuclear energy represented 24%, leaving fossil fuels at a historic low of 28%. In Germany, the Fraunhofer Institute reported similarly, stating that renewable energy contributed to 62.7% of the country's electricity production, a record-breaking figure.

As the share of wind and solar energy increases, the inherent unpredictability associated with weather-dependent energy production—often referred to as "weather-dependent" energy—poses larger challenges for balancing supply and demand in the electricity market

Advertisements

The phenomenon of negative pricing is likely to become more commonplace, complicating the balance of the European power system significantlyThe surge in renewable energy installations and generated power is not being matched by a corresponding rise in energy storage and related infrastructuresLiu noted that current energy storage capacities in Europe lag behind anticipated targetsBy 2030, an estimated 100 GW of storage capacity will be needed to effectively balance electricity supply and demand, a goal that remains distant given current capacity levels.

"The increasing frequency of negative pricing reflects the critical period of energy transition Europe is experiencingAddressing the challenges necessitates synchronizing investments in renewable energy generation, planning for energy storage development, managing the scale of fossil fuel-generated power, and reducing dependency on imported natural gas, while accelerating the construction of interconnected power grids across Europe," Liu added.

At the consumer level, the effects of negative pricing have not yet materialized

• Factors Influencing Energy Futures Market
• Trends in Financial Technology Development
• Trends in Capital Flows in Emerging Markets
• Meeting the Needs of Foreign Enterprises
• Applications of Supply Chain Finance

DrShi Shixuan, a senior researcher at the University of International Business and Economics and the director of the China-Germany Economic and Trade Research Center, shared insights about receiving a utility bill for 2023. In Germany, households typically prepay their electricity fees annually, adjusting after receiving billsThus, the immediate impact of negative pricing on consumers remains unseen, with electricity prices having remained relatively stable over the past two years.

For industrial entities equipped with energy storage facilities, negative pricing could indeed present opportunities for reduced operational costsUpon the emergence of negative pricing, companies with storage systems can charge during these periods without incurring costs, and even receive subsidies from grid companiesSubsequently, during peak usage, they can discharge stored energy, effectively sidestepping elevated grid prices

However, on a broader scale, Europe still faces considerable barriers to achieving low electricity prices, a change that cannot solely hinge on reducing generation costs.

DrShi elaborated on historical government actions aimed at promoting renewable energyBefore 2022, the German government employed high electricity rates on consumers to subsidize clean energy production through renewable energy plantsHowever, after revising their Renewable Energy Sources Act in the summer of 2022, subsidies dwindled to negligible amounts as the costs of producing renewable energy fell below those of traditional fossil fuelsConsequently, Germany's industries have been grappling with high electricity prices, stemming not only from reduced imports of Russian natural gas and the shutdown of nuclear power plants but also from the fact that only about 35% of the electricity costs can be attributed to generation; the bulk pertains to transmission fees, generation taxes, and value-added taxes

Thus, even when wholesale prices dip or negative rates occur, cumulative costs continue to keep end-user electricity prices significant.

According to DrShi, the current German government's measures to alleviate corporate electricity expenses focused on lowering electricity taxes and modifying renewable energy lawsHowever, expectations for lowering transmission fees as a future remedy are likely to yield limited improvements in addressing the industrial high-cost electricity predicament.

Furthermore, DrTu Jianjun emphasized that the heightened energy prices across Europe stem from systemic issues, principally attributed to the discontinuation of cheap Russian natural gasThis seismic shift in availability presents challenges that cannot be seamlessly mitigated by simply ramping up renewable energy generation in the short termThus, the crux of the issue lies at the intersection of Europe's energy market dynamics and broader geopolitical realities.